Skip to content
CiderHQ
Search

Learn

What "craft" and "traditional" mean

Does "craft cider" mean anything?

In short

Not as a legal term. Neither "craft" nor "traditional" is defined in law for cider in the United Kingdom, the United States or the European Union, and no authority verifies either claim before it goes on a label.

They do carry conventional meanings. Craft usually implies a small producer and an intention to make something distinctive; traditional usually implies full-juice cider from cider fruit, fermented slowly and without heavy processing. Both are implications rather than requirements.

The words that do carry weight are the specific ones: a stated juice percentage, a named variety, a protected designation, an unfiltered or bottle-conditioned claim, or a stated absence of concentrate. Those can be checked; the adjectives cannot.

Why the words are unregulated

Food labelling law in most jurisdictions prohibits statements that are false or misleading, but it defines relatively few descriptive terms outright. Where a term has been defined — organic, or a protected geographical name — that has taken a specific legal instrument. No such instrument exists for craft or traditional in cider.

That leaves the general prohibition on misleading the consumer as the only constraint. It is a real constraint, but it bites on factual claims rather than on adjectives: a producer who states a juice content they do not have is in difficulty, while one who calls an industrially produced cider traditional is making a claim too vague to test.

The situation is not unique to cider. Craft has drifted the same way in beer, where several attempts at a formal definition have been made by trade bodies with a commercial interest in where the line falls. Trade-body definitions of this kind are worth reading as positions rather than as neutral standards.

What each word conventionally implies

Common label terms, their conventional implication, and whether anything verifies them.
TermUsual implicationLegal statusWhat would actually verify it
CraftSmall producer, distinctive intent, limited volumeUndefined everywhereNothing on the label; producer scale can sometimes be checked independently
TraditionalFull juice, cider fruit, slow fermentation, minimal processingUndefined, except where part of a protected name such as Traditional Welsh CiderA protected designation, or a specific method claim
FarmhouseMade on a farm from its own fruit, in a traditional mannerUndefinedNothing; the term is used by producers of every size
Real ciderFull juice, unpasteurised, not carbonated, still fermenting or capable of itA campaigning definition, not a legal oneThe consumer organisation that maintains the definition applies it at its own events
Artisan, handcrafted, small batchSmall scale and manual methodUndefinedNothing
ScrumpyRough, still, strong West Country farmhouse ciderUndefined; historically a regional wordNothing; used commercially across a wide range of products

The claims that do carry information

How to use the words anyway

None of this makes the terms useless. They tell you how a producer wants their product understood, and that is genuine information about intent even when it is not information about content. A cider marketed as traditional is usually made by someone who thinks tradition is what their customers value, and often by someone who is in fact making cider that way.

The failure mode is treating the adjective as evidence. A reader who wants to know whether a cider is full juice, made from cider fruit and fermented slowly should look for those three statements, not for a word that gestures at all three without committing to any of them.

Also answered on this page

Questions this page covers, so you can tell at a glance whether it is the one you want.

Related

What people ask next

Questions readers ask about the things this page mentions. Each one goes to the section that answers it rather than to a page written to receive the question.

Sources

What this page rests on. Where a source is marked as registered rather than read, CiderHQ is recording that the body is authoritative on the subject without claiming to have worked through the document itself. See our evidence policy for what each state means.

Where to go next